LGR and highways: choosing a delivery model for a new unitary

When councils merge, their highway services rarely line up. The delivery model a new authority inherits is usually an accident of history. This is how we’d approach the choice.

What the new council inherits

Reorganisation brings together two or more predecessor councils, each with its own arrangements. One may have an outsourced term contract, another an in-house operation, a third a mix of frameworks for professional services. Contract end dates fall at different times. Asset data, systems and staff terms all differ.

None of this was designed to work together, and the new authority is accountable for all of it from Day 1.

Don’t choose the model on day one

There’s pressure to pick a model early so there’s something to announce. The first decision is really about continuity: keep services running safely, protect statutory duties and buy enough time to choose well.

That may mean short, controlled extensions or a transitional arrangement rather than a rushed procurement. A considered interim step is better than a permanent mistake.

Start with a shared baseline

Before comparing options, build one picture of what’s delivered, by whom, at what cost and to what standard. Map where each contract ends, how good the asset data is and which risks sit with the client.

Without that baseline, an options appraisal compares opinions rather than facts.

Compare the options honestly

The usual options are a single outsourced term contract, a mixed economy with an in-house core and specialist contracts, a wholly owned company, or a fully in-house service. Each moves risk, control and cost in a different way.

The right answer depends on the client capability the new council can sustain, the state of the local market and how much change the organisation can absorb at once.

Build the client before the contract

Whatever the model, the authority needs an intelligent client function that can set standards, manage performance and own decisions. It’s often the part that gets squeezed when budgets are tight.

We plan it, staff it and test it before go-live, because every other part of the model depends on it.

Plan the transition as one programme

People, systems, data, HSEQ and governance have to move together. Set a realistic Day 1, agree what good enough looks like on that day, and be clear about what follows later.

Facing something similar?

Let’s talk about what you’re dealing with.